Review of the BlackBerry PlayBook Part 1: The Hardware

POSTED BY: | Follow Me

May 18, 2024

CLICK HERE TO COMMENT (5)

Before I get into this review, I’m going to do something I do quite often: take you on a trip down memory lane. Why? Because if you are reading this, you appreciate my writing; and I am a sentimental guy like that.

I was raised in a very old fashioned, modest, middle class, Eastern European (Romanian) household; needless to say, nothing was handed to us (by us I am referring to my two sisters). We were raised to not only work for what we want, but to also respect and appreciate what we get and even more so — have patience with it, as nothing is perfect. This value has been instilled in me from the time I got my first pair of rollerblades, then bicycle, and as I aged to my first car, first phone (a Motorola StarTac), and now, my first (yes, this is the first time I have owned one, all up-to-now have been on-loan review units) personal tablet.

Whether in development or launched to the masses, everything is a work in progress and the BlackBerry PlayBook is no exception. The difference this time around is that RIM needs the PlayBook and its QNX operating system to succeed, not only to reinstill stockholder confidence, but to keep their swaying fan boys from jumping ship. RIM realizes very well that Apple and Google are rapidly pulling the rug right out from under them, not only in terms of OS market share, but in terms of popularity too. So, one could boldly argue the PlayBook to be RIM throwing their middle finger up at iOS and Android saying: “Guess what, we’re here too, so stand the eff back”. Well, after using the device for two solid weeks, and now with the recent update including Video Chat and BBM over BlackBerry Bridge, my finger is slowly creaking up to RIM’s competition as well. Read on to find out why…..

The Hardware: Yes, like many-a-smart phone-user I like something to be comfortable in the hands — cue the annoyingly infamous “that’s what she said” quote, har har — and the PlayBook is the first tablet I have ever used that I can comfortably transport. Whether in the back pocket of my jeans or in my laptop bag; I feel as though RIM really researched this aspect, taking example from the already released fan favourites iPad and Galaxy Tab by going smaller and slimmer than both. I, for one, appreciate the smooth matte finish on the back of the PlayBook over the “grip” style backing found on the Galaxy Tab and aluminum backing of the iPad; many will surely disagree with this statement, but this is my review, not theirs ;) .

Part of the hardware includes the design and unique layout of certain features which deserve mention; namely the power button, or in my opinion, the lack thereof. I honestly don’t know what RIM was thinking with it — it’s awkwardly designed to say the least; awkwardly small and positioned to the left of the equally-as-awkward volume rocker. It seems like the only way to get a response from it, is to actually exert hard, physical pressure. I have been using a Case-Mate case with my PlayBook since attending BlackBerry World - and though, in Case-Mate’s defence the case is otherwise very well designed - I am even more annoyed when trying to press power with the case on. The spacing between the material of the case and power button makes it next to impossible to turn the device off or on. Fortunately, RIM did suggest at a gesture update to come, where the device can be turned off/on with a simple swipe-up of the screen; so I’ll chalk this one up to simply an oversight during quality control.

One thing I do appreciate, though, is the positioning of the microUSB charging port, HDMI out, and copper connectors for the desktop stand; they simply work. They are subtly at the bottom of the device, but easily accessible for use, with or without a protective case. And lastly, what is a device — tablet or phone — if we don’t talk about the sound it emanates? Or in the PlayBook’s case, the sound it projects. You will be pleasantly surprised with how clear and crisp the sound created by these speakers is. Regardless of whether you listen to hard rock, hip-hop or house, rest assured you can comfortably relax in your backyard this summer with the PlayBook playing music and you will hear the sound clearly; that is unless you have friends over, then you’ll have to bust out the WOWee speaker. While we are on the topic of clarity let’s move on to another very important aspect of the PlayBook….

The Screen: At 600 x 1024 pixels and 7.0 inches diagonally, it’s a doppelgänger of the Galaxy Tab (minus the Gorilla glass). It is also very similar to the display of both iPads except for one thing: the picture quality; it’s actually unreal — play one of the preloaded promo videos and see for yourself, it’s stunning. The PlayBook screen’s colors are vibrant and eye-popping at all times, leaving you wanting more as you swipe and choose your way through the new environment. Another added bonus to the gorgeous screen is how well RIM implemented its touch capabilities, which quite frankly is RIM’s best commercially released offering in this niche. Maybe it has the new 1GHz dual-core Cortex-A9 CPU processor to thank, but finally RIM hit the nail on the head with this one; I actually look forward to typing, gaming, and just gesturing on it because of how fluent it is. And despite being only 7″ it seems to work well, whether gaming or just killing time — gone are those pesky hourglasses which often consume the BlackBerry OS experience. Don’t get me wrong though, this isn’t to say that a larger, say 10″, screen wouldn’t be even hotter, but at 7″ it still does what many are looking for from this tablet: respond gracefully.

 

A photo of a street in the Downsview area of Toronto taken with the back (main) camera of the BlackBerry PlayBook (16GB version) on May 18, 2011.

ABOVE: A photo of a street in Toronto, Canada taken with the PlayBook’s back facing 5MP Camera. Click to see it in full 2592 x 1456 resolution.

BELOW: A photo of the same street as above taken with the PlayBook’s front facing 3.2MP camera 2 minutes after the one taken above. I tried to get as close to the same exact picture as I could. Click to see it in full 2048 x 1152 resolution.

A photo of a street in the Downsview area of Toronto taken with the front camera of the BlackBerry PlayBook (16GB version) on May 18, 2011.

The Camera: Would it be too bold to say that this camera stacks up with the iPhone? To put it bluntly, not really. At 5MP, the rear camera equals the iPhone’s resolution-wise and shoots video in stunning 1080p vs the iPhone & iPad’s 720p. What about the front facing camera? Makes FaceTime look bad; at 3MP the picture and call quality are crisp, clear (we will get deeper into video chat when I touch on usability in the next part of the review) and almost inviting to use. Only one thing that kind of irks me — and I think should be standard by now — is the lack of a flash for the camera. How do they realistically expect me (or you) to take ANY decent pictures in low or poorly lit settings? It’s hard to rely on lighting when a “Kodak” moment arises, and frankly RIM should have known better; all their smartphones with a 3.2MP camera or better have a flash, what makes the PlayBook any different?

The first half of my review is done, but the review is far from over. You see, one thing I have learned from countless long reviews is that most people don’t have the time — or even patience- to read through thousands of words at once. That being said; read over, think about it and converse in the comments. The next and final half, my thoughts on QNX and its usability will come in the next couple of days. Till then…

  • http://twitter.com/phishgirl3 Michelle Haag

    I agree with you about the camera needing a flash. Before I even got my PlayBook, I was disappointed to learn it wouldn’t have one.
    However I disagree about the power button. In the three-ish weeks I’ve had my PB, I think I’ve used the power button twice. I just don’t need to use it. I use a swipe to turn it on and just let it go to sleep on its own. Seems to me that most reviews covered the button as a hardware flaw, which, since that’s the main one that everyone complains about (and it’s pretty insignificant, be honest) then RIM really did a bang up job with their first tablet. :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Gregory-John-Wesson/1142661895 Gregory John Wesson

    Corey, solid review on the hardware. I’m with Michelle on this one, though. Maybe it’s my fingers, but I have no difficulty with the power button when I need it, which is seldom. Granted, mine is raised, but my fingers at this point know that once off the left side volume rocker, I’m on the power button.

    Things I missed in your review:
    The headset jack. While one would think that it is a given today, tell that to HPalm on their Veer.
    The dual stereo microphones. Having listened on the PlayBook to things recorded from a PlayBook, it’s amazing to hear the beautiful stereo sound the mics pick up.
    Lack of removeble battery: I was surprised when I first learned that the battery was going to be internal and not accessible for the quick swap. My bet was that they were going for such solid battery life, there would be no need for swapping. Add multiple charging solutions and why make the battery removeable? I don’t think it makes a difference for me, but I can see where heavy users would want the option. RIM could have had a internal back up battery that would run the PlayBook during a battery switch. My two cents.
    2.1 speakers: This is just being nit-picky. Today, we’re well into 7.1 surround, so how hard would it have been to add a top or bottom center speaker? Entirely my preference, but I feel like it could have been done and really impressed the audiophiles.

    Looking forward to part 2, sir!

    -lombaki/gregerator

  • http://www.techguysmartbuy.com Roderick Scott

    Well said. Can’t wait to check out the next part of the review. I personally love mines just need a few key apps, a few people to video chat with and i’m good to go.

  • http://twitter.com/pozi240 Andrew Poziomka

    Once again Corey, an expertly written and very well thought out review, every point made is “spot on”, and if I didn’t already have a PB, your review would have made me “feel” like I was using the PB myself…… anyone curious about this tablet would do well to read your reviews!

  • Kiel

    great review!!! this is the first time i have read one of your reviews and from now on will be looking forward to them.
    Its nice to see that someone actually use it for more then a day or two before talking badly about it. I have had mine from release day and have been very happy with mine and as for the power button issue, i have large hands so everyone else tells me and i dont have any issue using the power button and i usually shut mine off every day before work. M y only real issue so far is the lack of good games like the need for speed but i know they will come and when the do i’ll be waiting. I also hope you put in your second part of the review about using the hdmi out. i picked up the cable yesterday and hook it up to show my mom. She was amazed about the quality of the picture, and they are not kidding on how powerful it is. I had a music video running on her tv and was running twitter, the facebook app, app world and need for speed all running at the same time and the playbook didnt miss a beat!!
    Again great review and cant wait for the second part

FPNews


The Phone Fixer


QR Agency


Task Ave.

FEATURED STORIES:

BEST PHONES:


The Phone Fixer

What's the wagjag

TheCellularGuru's choice Twitter App for iPhone

CONTACT US TWITTER PRIVACY POLICY © Copyright 2010 | All rights reserved | The Cellular Guru Inc.